|  | | | Customer Reviews: | | | Average Customer Review: ( 11 customer reviews )
Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
170 of 173 found the following review helpful:
 Lots of features but not a lot of education... Dec 21, 2004
By Jim Moore
This 500-in-1 kit has more features than the average attention span can handle (I won't re-hash the list here. You can find the complete list of projects online somewhere).
So, this is not a "Well, this looks like a good gift for Johnny" product. Whoever is going to receive (if it's a gift) or purchase for themselves, should be fairly serious about learning electronics. If not, start with a much smaller kit, and work yourself up to this one.
As far as construction, it's pretty sturdy. The breadboard is centrally located and from a layout perspective, I had no trouble setting up any of the experiments.
****** NOTE *******
There are a TON of resistors, wires, caps, etc.
I ended up buying a couple plastic partitioned containers to hold everything and that still wasn't enough. Pretty much everything comes in an individually marked plastic bag, and Tesla help you if you don't take care in replacing everything back into the correct baggie, or you'll quickly memorize the Resistor Identification chart...though, that may not be a bad side-effect :)
*********************
I did have some trouble with the breadboard itself, in that some of the slots were really tough to punch into and with my big sausage-like fingers, I ended up bending a few leads and wire ends here and there and settled on using some needle nose pliers to feed the tough slots.
The experiments are split up into 3 large softbound manuals (Aprox 10"x14") and cover a very wide range of projects. There are "Did you know" type blurbs throughout which makes them informative.
****** NOTE *******
My biggest problem with this kit is with the text of the experiments. I found myself wanting more "This is what's happening and why" type of information, but what you get is mostly just how to set up the project. IMHO, it's missing 1 or 2 more paragraphs talking about the Why of the project.
**********************
Ironically, the most use I actually got out of this kit, was to prototype and test some circuts and devices (motors, lights, solenoids, etc) using the breadboard and the variable resistor pots, but I've since purchased a breadboard from R.S. and some basic wires/resistors/caps/etc that allow me to do all that.
My ADD only allowed me to trek through the first manual before I saw another shiny object and left this kit to gather dust in the closet. If you are serious about using a kit to learn electronics, then this is probably for you. If you are looking at it from a hobby view, I'd recommend starting with something smaller.
(Sorry for the long review, but since no one else has submited one, I figured I'd try to be of some help)
18 of 18 found the following review helpful:
 Tons of fun, but not much learning value Jun 30, 2010
By Stefan Brunner
There are not many vendors of experimentation sets, and electronic sets in particular, left anymore. Most vanished to the begin of the 90th. There is Kosmos as the market leader, Busch, and Elenco, and a variety of small vendors who sell direct. The Elenco 500-in-One offers an amazing value for the amount of parts and scope of experiments one can do. Unfortunately, the instruction booklets are of little help. Each lab has a diagram and a few words of text. The diagram is sufficient to build the lab but the three words of text do nothing to explain why things work as they work. I think for a child or a teenager this set has value as it offers a lot of fun to build pretty complex and interesting electronic stuff, when compared to other experimentation kits, but does little for the education on learning how to develop your own. As a toy, it is a good alternative for some hands-on in a world of virtualization through game consoles, iPhone, and massive multiplayer online games.
This said, you will find in the the 500-in-One a fun electronic toy which you can also use as a basis for your own electronics studies with the choice of your favorite text book. If you prefer the later, however, you can also get a breadboard and parts according to your own needs.
If you are looking for alternatives, I can recommend Kosmos Electronics Workshop 2 (XN 3000, Electronic Pofi) for older kids and adults as well as Elenco Snap Circuits which is ideal in particular for young children (my 3 year old daughter enjoys snapping together simple circuits which make a lamp glow or a motor spin.) There are also many smaller vendors, some attached to publishers of magazines and some individuals, offerings sets about different topics. Also Lego Mindstorms with its very custimizable I2C and analog interfaces (book "Extreme NXT" shows you how) or the very flexible German Fischertechnik Computing series can be nice compliments (or alternatives) to build electronically controlled machines and robots without tools.
14 of 17 found the following review helpful:
very good to learn on .. Jul 22, 2008
By The President
"of the United States of America"
but not for your average kid. Unlike the less expensive circuit kits, this one comes with bags of loose components. That is better for learning, b ut is not good for the disorganized or those kids that are looking for FUNFUN FUN right now. I would recommend this item for those over 17 .. and especially those REALLY wanting to learn about electrionics.
I am 23 and am using this kit to explore the hobby of electronics. I also recommend the book "electronic circuits for dummies" .. which is much better written than the manual included with the 500-in-one kit, and much easier to understand/learn from.
5 of 5 found the following review helpful:
Lots of components at a fair price Aug 16, 2010
By P. McWhorter
This kit pretty much is as advertised. It has lots of components, and enough variety to fill several years of class time. It can be used as an affordable way to create an electronics lab in an educational setting. The kit has the components necessary to teach analog circuits, digital circuits, and even micro-controller programming.
My major gripe with this kit is that as delivered, it is of almost no educational value. The three books that come with it, describing the 500 projects, simply show how to connect components together to create circuits that do various things. It gives NO explanation of what part of the circuit is doing what, and what different components are doing. It just has you blindly plugging pieces together. If it is to be used as a meaningful educational tool, instructor must develop a curriculum around it, and use it as an affordable source of components. Most of the projects are too complex to use as educational tools, as they are beyond simple introductory analysis.
With that being said, I found the kit very useful. In an educational setting, you will need to combine it with a DVM, waveform generator, and an oscilloscope, which are all fairly affordable these days. With these, and some real work in developing relevant supporting material, this kit can serve as the basis of a really good electronics education.
20 of 26 found the following review helpful:
Notes from an old technohobbiest Mar 01, 2007
By Oldtechnohobbiest
"Mr. Nobody"
Howdy-the old technohobbiest here. I just received in the mail Elenco MX-909 500-in-1 Electronic Project Lab...I might add ANM Enterprises shipped this ten pound box to me within a week!
Anyway, I write some up dates to this short review later on as I use the kit.
Meanwhile; as I look at the kit (overall) it appears to be worth every cent. If you look at the picture at the top of the page you'll notice the shiny plastic area just above the key pad--this is not an LCD or LED display but is the battery box cover in clear plastic. Also you'll notice two yellow apparently plastic tabs (one on the left and one on the right side) on the bottom of the console. They stick straight up on either side of the console and lend one the idea they are 'snap lock' tabs to hold the breif case closed...they are not. They are pull tabs to pull up two metal arms that can be attached to the upper section so the breif case will not close on your hand or open fully up--this is a good thing because some of us want our experiments on the fat and level.
The breadboard is almost centered. It is the smaller version but large enough for half a dozen small circuits at one time. Measures 4 1/2 inches wide by 2 3/4 inches high. The key pad also has an ENTER, STOP, RUN function keys and several others that are not numbers.
Top right--of the top section--there is a black rectangle area in the photo looking like a switch or plug in area--not so it is an LED digi display box.
Bottom section--top left--another shiny plastic area, this is a built in load antenna standard for most portable radioes. All switches but one are located on the bottom section--they are all grey plastic knobs and push-and slide switches. The numeric pads is all lite grey and spring return switches. Your on/off switch is the one grey switch on the top section. That black square area in the center of the top section shows where the processor chip is and can be ignored for now.
I'll update this later when I know more.
See all 11 customer reviews on Amazon.com
|
| | |
